Chapter 1: The Idea of Owning a Boat to Catch Fish
If you enjoy fishing, it is only natural to imagine taking your own boat offshore and fishing wherever you want, for as long as you want.
You take the helm yourself, search for promising spots with a fish finder, and drop a line wherever something catches your attention.
You are no longer tied to the schedule of a shared fishing boat or to another captain’s decisions.
That freedom is appealing, and it is easy to understand why an angler might start thinking about buying a pleasure boat.
I own a pleasure boat myself and regularly take it out to sea.
This article is based on my experience in Japan, but I suspect the basic structure is much the same elsewhere: boats are expensive tools for catching fish, and once paying customers come aboard, freedom begins to turn into responsibility.
That is precisely why I have come to think that owning a pleasure boat mainly for the purpose of catching fish is a poor bargain.
The value of owning a boat cannot be measured by the catch alone.
Operating the boat yourself.
Choosing where to go.
Spending an entire day at sea.
Entering a harbor you have never visited before.
If you enjoy all of those experiences, boat ownership takes on a very different value.
But if your only objective is to catch more fish, a pleasure boat suddenly becomes an extraordinarily expensive piece of fishing equipment.
Once you own one, another idea may also occur to you:
“Perhaps I could occasionally take a few paying anglers out and use the income to offset some of the running costs.”
In this article, I want to look at two ideas:
owning a pleasure boat as a means of catching fish
and
using a privately owned recreational boat for a small-scale fishing-charter side business.
The expenses of a pleasure boat continue long after the purchase.
Marina or mooring fees.
Insurance.
Routine maintenance.
Bottom painting.
Engine oil and consumables.
Repairs when equipment fails.
And fuel every time you go out.
As the boat becomes larger and engine power increases, these costs generally rise as well.
For example, suppose a boat costs ¥1.5 million per year to maintain.
If you use it 20 times a year, that alone works out to ¥75,000 per outing.
Fuel and other costs for the day come on top of that.
By comparison, a seat on a shared fishing charter in Japan often costs around ¥10,000 for a day of fishing.
The customer does not maintain the boat.
The customer does not refuel it.
Pre-departure engine checks and washing the boat after returning are someone else’s job.
Weather assessment, navigation, and safety management are handled by the captain.
If catching fish is the only objective, paying for a fishing charter is far more efficient than owning the boat yourself.
Chapter 3: Owning the Boat Does Not Automatically Mean Catching More Fish
With your own boat, you can go where you want.
You can leave when you want.
You can move freely between spots while watching your own fish finder.
That freedom is a major attraction.
But freedom does not automatically translate into a larger catch.
A professional charter captain may have spent years watching the same waters.
Seasonal fish movements.
The relationship between tides and fishing grounds.
Which species have been caught recently, and where.
That knowledge accumulates day after day.
For a recreational owner who goes out only occasionally, matching that volume of local experience is difficult.
Fishing itself is also affected by many variables: tides, water temperature, wind, baitfish, the location of fish schools, and fish activity.
Owning an expensive boat does not give you control over what the fish decide to do.
As I wrote in No Catch? No Problem ★ Enjoying Boat Fishing Through Imagination and Experimentation, fishing is not an activity with highly reproducible results.
A pleasure boat greatly expands your freedom to choose where and when you fish.
That freedom and the catch are two different kinds of value.
Chapter 4: “Maybe I Can Take a Few Customers Out and Offset the Costs”
Once you start looking at the running costs of a boat, another idea can seem attractive.
“If I take a few anglers out on weekends, perhaps the income could cover part of the boat’s expenses.”
At first, the logic seems reasonable.
But this is where the nature of the boat begins to change.
Once you repeatedly take paying customers fishing, you are no longer simply using the boat for private recreation. You are operating a commercial fishing-charter service.
Depending on the country or region, that can bring licensing requirements, insurance obligations, commercial operating rules, and additional safety responsibilities.
The boat changes from
a boat you use for your own recreation
into
a boat used to carry paying customers safely to sea.
The hull may be exactly the same.
The responsibility is not.
Chapter 5: A Small Side Business Has a Low Revenue Ceiling
Let us use the same example of a boat costing ¥1.5 million per year to maintain.
Suppose a 24-foot boat carries three fishing customers, each paying ¥10,000.
Revenue from one trip is ¥30,000.
Even if you operate 30 such trips a year, annual revenue is only ¥900,000.
Fuel and other direct operating expenses for those charter days still have to come out of that revenue.
So you have a boat carrying an annual ownership burden of ¥1.5 million and a small charter operation producing ¥900,000 in gross annual revenue after 30 trips.
When you put the numbers on paper, occasionally carrying a few paying customers is a difficult way to make a major dent in the cost of a privately owned boat.
A commercial operator with an established boat, mooring, local knowledge, customer base, and enough operating days can build a viable fishing-charter business.
A recreational owner who occasionally takes a few customers out on a small pleasure boat faces a different economic structure.
Revenue per trip is limited.
That low revenue ceiling is the fundamental weakness of the small side-business model.
Chapter 6: Once Customers Pay, Safety Becomes the Job
When I go to sea by myself, I can make decisions entirely for myself.
Start fishing.
Move somewhere else.
Head home.
I choose everything according to my own circumstances.
With paying customers aboard, however, their safety becomes the priority.
Keeping watch.
Changes in weather and sea conditions.
Boat position.
Other vessels.
Shallow water.
Fishing gear in the water.
The physical condition of the passengers.
The risk of falls or going overboard.
The captain suddenly has far more to monitor.
Commercial fishing-charter operations are built around the operator’s responsibility for passenger safety.
There is a large gap between the image of
“I’ll do some fishing myself while taking a few paying customers along”
and the reality of
“operating a fishing charter.”
The price customers pay is not merely the price of a place on the boat.
Part of what they are paying for is the captain accepting responsibility for their safety.
To me, that is one of the biggest differences between taking a boat out for recreation and taking it out as a business.
Chapter 7: A Pleasure Boat Does Not Fit Neatly Into the Category of “Fishing Gear”
So far, I have judged the boat mainly by its usefulness for catching fish.
By that measure, a pleasure boat is an extraordinarily expensive piece of fishing equipment.
If all you want is a day of fishing, shared fishing charters exist.
If you want a smaller degree of independence on the water, options such as a fishing kayak involve much less storage and maintenance.
So why choose a pleasure boat?
I think the answer appears once you stop looking at the boat solely as a tool for catching fish.
A boat gets you to fishing grounds, but operating the boat is also an activity in its own right.
Taking the helm.
Navigating.
Anchoring.
Entering a harbor.
Simply spending time at sea.
Seen that way, a pleasure boat no longer fits neatly into the category of fishing gear.
Chapter 8: What You Are Buying Is Not Fish, but Freedom
I own a pleasure boat.
There are experiences I can have only because I go to sea in my own boat.
Where should I go today?
Which route should I take?
Where should I anchor?
Should I fish?
Should I swim?
Should I enter a harbor?
Should I simply float offshore and do nothing?
I decide all of it.
That is a completely different kind of value from the number of fish I bring home.
What I am buying with a pleasure boat is not fish. It is the freedom to decide how I spend my time and where I go on the water.
Fishing is only one of the things I can enjoy within that freedom.
Conclusion: As a Tool for Catching Fish, a Pleasure Boat Does Not Pay
It is perfectly natural for an angler to want a boat of their own.
Having your own boat can greatly expand the world of fishing.
But if the sole objective is
to own a boat in order to catch more fish,
the costs, labor, maintenance, and safety responsibilities are substantial.
If you then try to recover those costs by running a small fishing-charter business, you take on a new responsibility: the safety of other people at sea.
That is why I think:
As a tool for catching fish, owning a pleasure boat simply does not pay.
But if what you are buying is the freedom to go to sea—even when that freedom does not make financial sense—the calculation changes completely.
It costs money.
It takes work.
Some days the weather keeps you in port.
Some days you catch nothing.
And you still want to take your own boat out to sea.
For someone who feels that way, a pleasure boat stops being just an expensive piece of fishing equipment.
For those who can enjoy a kind of freedom that cannot be fully explained by economic rationality, owning a boat can make perfect sense.
Want to know more about the author and the thinking behind this site?
→ About Rikutsu-Kone-Taro
