When you start looking at used boats, you sometimes come across one that seems unbelievably cheap.
A boat that was once expensive when new may now be listed for a fraction of its original price after sitting unused for years.
When you find something like that, it is natural to think:
“This might be a real bargain.”
But before focusing on the asking price, there is another question that makes the price much easier to understand:
What still needs to be done before this boat is ready for normal use?
With a boat that has gone for years without sufficient maintenance, some of the money required to bring it back into usable condition simply has not yet been spent.
In other words, a very cheap used boat may be:
a boat being sold with part of the cost of making it ready to use still left for the buyer to pay.
The asking price alone does not tell you whether a boat is really cheap
In simple terms:
Long-neglected used boat + necessary repairs = usable used boat
Suppose you have two similar boats:
- Long-neglected boat: ¥3 million
- Properly serviced boat: ¥6 million
If it costs ¥3.5 million to bring the ¥3 million boat up to roughly the same condition as the ¥6 million boat, the total becomes ¥6.5 million.
The boat that looked ¥3 million cheaper at the beginning ends up costing ¥500,000 more by the time it is ready to use.
The figures in this article are illustrative. I use yen because the original discussion comes from a Japanese boating perspective.
With a used boat, it helps to separate:
the price on the listing
from
the total amount required to make the boat ready for normal use.
Repair costs on an old, neglected boat can be difficult to predict
A boat contains a large number of mechanical and electrical systems.
There is the engine, fuel system, electrical wiring, plumbing, steering system, pumps, electronics and more.
The hull itself also contains structural components such as decks, bulkheads and the transom.
And boats live in an environment full of salt, moisture, water and ultraviolet exposure.
On a boat that has gone a long time without adequate maintenance, deterioration may have progressed in places that are not immediately visible.
The engine starts.
Then a problem appears when it is placed under load on the water.
You touch old wiring and discover corrosion inside it.
You replace a hose and find another deteriorated component farther down the system.
You open part of the deck and discover that the structure beneath it also needs work.
With an old boat, one repair can reveal the next.
That makes it difficult to know in advance:
how much it will ultimately cost to make the boat normally usable again.
With a very cheap boat, the buyer may therefore be taking on not only repair costs, but also:
the fact that the final repair bill is still unknown.
“It can be repaired” and “it is worth repairing” are different questions
A great deal can be repaired on a boat.
But the fact that something can be repaired does not mean that spending the money makes sense for that particular boat.
If spending ¥1 million on repairs increases the boat’s market value by ¥2 million, there may be a good reason to do the work.
If spending ¥3 million increases its value by only ¥1 million, the calculation is very different.
And if major structural work is required, repair costs can rise very quickly.
Professionals who deal in used boats think about the same two questions:
How much will it cost to make this boat properly sale-ready?
and
How much will the boat actually sell for once the work is done?
A dealer looks at what the boat will be worth after the work is done
Repairing a used boat can increase its value.
But spending ¥1 million on repairs does not necessarily increase its market price by ¥1 million.
Used boats have an approximate market value based on model, age, engines, equipment, popularity and other factors.
The final selling price also depends on how many people actually want that particular boat at that price.
So a seller has to think about:
What can I buy it for, what will it cost to prepare it for resale, and what can I realistically sell it for afterward?
Buy it for ¥1 million, spend ¥1 million on it, sell it for ¥2 million—and that still isn’t a viable business
Suppose a dealer buys a boat for ¥1 million.
Repairs, parts, cleaning and other preparation cost another ¥1 million.
The dealer now has ¥2 million invested in the boat.
If it sells for ¥2 million:
¥1 million + ¥1 million = ¥2 million
The money invested in the boat has merely come back.
But a real business also has to deal with storage, sales activity, labor, the time capital is tied up, the possibility that the boat takes longer than expected to sell, and support after the sale.
For the job to make sense commercially, the dealer needs enough margin after those costs and risks.
For illustration, suppose we call:
- Purchase price: X
- Cost of preparing the boat for sale: Y
and imagine that the dealer would like to see a possible selling price somewhere around:
(X + Y) × 1.3
This is not an industry rule or a standard used-boat margin.
It is simply an easy way to illustrate the basic idea.
If a dealer buys a boat for ¥1 million and spends another ¥1 million preparing it, the total investment is ¥2 million.
A sale at ¥2.6 million creates a ¥600,000 margin before the remaining costs of doing business are taken into account.
That margin has to absorb storage, sales expenses, labor, time and risk.
For a professional, the important question is therefore not simply:
Will the boat be worth more after repairs?
It is:
Will enough margin remain after the entire process of buying, preparing and selling the boat is complete?
Professionals look at more than the repair bill
Two boats that could eventually sell for the same amount may be very different businesses.
A boat becomes easier to handle commercially when, for example:
- Parts are readily available
- The required repairs are reasonably predictable
- Transportation is straightforward
- It does not consume excessive storage space
- There are plenty of potential buyers
- It is likely to sell within a reasonable period
A boat that takes months to repair, occupies a large amount of yard space and may take a long time to find a buyer requires a larger margin to be attractive.
So a professional is not simply asking:
Can I buy this cheaply?
The real question is:
Can I buy it, prepare it properly, sell it, and still make enough money for the work to be worthwhile?
Professionals may see the boat before ordinary buyers ever see the listing
In sales channels involving dealers, marinas, repair yards and other marine businesses, professionals may have an opportunity to see a boat before the general public ever sees an advertisement for it.
If they conclude:
“We can buy this boat, put some work into it, and turn it into something buyers will want,”
then the boat has commercial value.
They buy it cheaply.
They repair what needs repairing.
They check the machinery and equipment.
They clean it up and prepare it for sale.
Then it appears on the used-boat market.
By the time an ordinary buyer sees it, the asking price may already reflect:
purchase price + preparation costs + the seller’s profit
The buyer may look at it and think:
“It looks good, but it seems a little expensive.”
But someone has already spent money, time and effort getting it to that point.
An obvious “bargain” is usually obvious to professionals too
Suppose a boat can be bought for ¥1 million.
Another ¥1 million would bring it into good saleable condition.
And once completed, it could realistically sell for ¥4 million.
That is an attractive proposition for a professional as well.
Professionals also have:
- Experience evaluating boats
- Knowledge of likely repair costs
- Established parts suppliers
- Repair facilities
- Knowledge of used-boat market prices
They may be able to recognize the opportunity faster than an ordinary buyer.
The clearer the potential margin, the more likely it is that the boat will be prepared for resale before an ordinary buyer ever sees it as a cheap project.
By the time it appears on the market,
what was once a cheap project may have become a properly prepared used boat—with a higher price to match.
So why is this particular boat still being sold so cheaply?
Now we can return to the original question.
There is a very cheap used boat in front of you.
A professional seller could potentially repair it and offer it later at a higher price.
Yet it is still being offered cheaply in its current condition.
One possible reason is that:
there is not enough margin between the cost of doing the work and the additional selling price the finished boat could command.
Perhaps it would cost ¥2 million to prepare the boat properly, but doing so would increase its selling price by only ¥1 million.
Or perhaps the finished boat would have a respectable market value, but repairs, storage, transport and the time required to sell it would consume too much of the margin.
For a dealer, that makes the boat less attractive as a project.
And so:
part of the work required to make the boat normally usable remains unfinished when the boat is offered at a low price.
That unfinished work is part of what the low asking price represents.
Doing the work yourself changes the calculation
At this point, many buyers think:
“I can save money by fixing it myself.”
That can be true, depending on the individual.
Suppose a professional could complete a job in 10 hours for ¥100,000.
You do the same job yourself, but it takes you 100 hours.
In that case:
you have used 100 hours of your own time to avoid ¥100,000 in outside labor costs.
When you do the work yourself, nobody sends you an invoice for your own time.
That makes the time invested in DIY work easy to overlook.
Boat repair also requires more than the physical ability to replace a part.
It may require experience diagnosing the real cause of a failure, proper tools, a suitable place to work and the ability to obtain the right parts.
On the other hand, the calculation can be very different for someone who already has:
- The skills to do the repairs
- A place to work
- Access to inexpensive parts
- Detailed knowledge of that particular type of boat
Such a person may be able to make sense of a boat that is unattractive to a commercial seller.
If restoration itself is enjoyable, the value of the time changes
For some people, restoring an old boat is part of the hobby.
Taking the boat apart.
Rewiring it.
Replacing old components.
Watching the boat gradually come back to life.
If that process is enjoyable in itself, then repair time is also recreational time.
For such a person, a long-neglected used boat may be:
not a cheap finished boat, but a project to be completed personally.
A boat that offers little commercial opportunity to a dealer may still be very attractive to an individual whose skills, tools and interests are different.
Look beyond the words “serviced” or “refurbished”
Some used boats receive work before being offered for sale.
But there is a limit to how much money can be spent preparing a boat when the eventual selling price is constrained by the market.
That can lead to work such as:
- Making the boat operational
- Cleaning up the areas buyers can easily see
- Replacing only the most necessary components
- Continuing to use older parts that are still functioning
In other words, the boat may receive minimal make-ready work or largely cosmetic refurbishment.
The result can look quite good.
With a used boat, it is often more useful to ask:
What exactly was repaired or replaced, and how far did the work go?
Parts replaced, maintenance records, details of the work performed and sea-trial results can tell you much more about what has actually been invested in the boat.
A pre-purchase inspection helps reduce the unknown repair bill
With a boat that has gone a long time without sufficient maintenance, the final cost can change dramatically depending on what is discovered after purchase.
That makes pre-purchase inspection important.
Look at the hull.
Look at the engine.
Inspect the fuel system, electrical system, plumbing and steering.
If possible, haul the boat out and inspect the underwater portion of the hull.
A sea trial allows the engine, steering, cooling system, vibration and onboard equipment to be checked under actual load.
On a more expensive boat, having an experienced independent person inspect the boat can also be worthwhile.
The money spent here can be understood as:
money spent before purchase to make some of the unknown repair bill visible before it becomes your repair bill.
Why properly serviced used boats are more expensive
When a dealer or manufacturer thoroughly inspects and repairs a used boat and also provides a meaningful warranty, the seller has already paid for a great deal of work.
That may include:
- Inspection
- Repairs
- Parts
- Labor
- Preparation for sale
- Warranty support after the sale
Those costs are reflected in the asking price.
That is why a properly prepared used boat is usually not especially cheap.
From the buyer’s perspective, the higher price may already include:
some of the repair costs and failure risk that the buyer would otherwise have had to take on after purchase.
A boat that is cheap to buy is not necessarily cheap to use
Once you look at the process step by step, the meaning of a very low used-boat price becomes easier to see.
A cheap boat may still have repairs waiting to be done.
The final cost of those repairs may be difficult to predict.
Professional sellers look at:
the purchase price, the cost of preparing the boat for resale, and the price it is likely to command afterward.
A boat with an obvious and large potential margin can be attractive to professionals too.
By the time such a boat reaches the ordinary buyer, some of that potential value may already have been converted into repairs, preparation and a higher asking price.
A boat that is still being offered very cheaply may therefore come with part of the work required to make it normally usable still left for the buyer.
That is why, with used boats:
a boat that is cheap to buy and a boat that is cheap to use are not the same thing.
And when looking at the asking price, the important question is not only:
How much does this boat cost?
It is also:
What has already been done to bring it to this price—and what is still left to do?
Want to know more about the author and the thinking behind this site?
→ About Rikutsu-Kone-Taro
